Will the UK sanction extremist Israeli ministers?
Smotrich and Ben-Gvir have urged Netanyahu to stop aid convoys getting into Gaza and encouraged extreme settlers in the West Bank.
David Cameron launched an attack today on two “extremist” ministers in Netanyahu’s government, revealing that he had been “working up sanctions against” the duo during his time as foreign secretary, writes Josh Schlicht.
According to Cameron, measures such as asset freezes and travel bans against Israel’s national security minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, and its finance minister, Bezalel Smotrich, were mulled over by the Tory government but put on hold due to the general election.
Cameron urged his successor, David Lammy, to consider such a move, stating, “Smotrich and Ben-Gvir have said things like encouraging people to stop aid convoys getting into Gaza and encouraging extreme settlers in the West Bank with the appalling things they have been carrying out… when ministers in your government are extremists and behave in this way, we are prepared to use our sanctions regime to say this is simply not good enough and has to stop”.
Smotrich and Ben-Gvir have been considered extreme in Israeli domestic politics for years prior to their ascension to government. The original political party Ben-Gvir was a member of was, the Kach and Kahane Chai party, which was designated as a terrorist organisation and outlawed by the Israeli government. Ben-Gvir himself has been indicted dozens of times and convicted of “incitement to racism and supporting a terror organisation”.
A year prior to the 7 October attacks, Ben-Gvir ignited a firestorm in Israel after brandishing his firearm towards stone-wielding Palestinians and urging police to “mow down” the agitated East Jerusalem crowd. In a separate instance, the national security minister pulled his gun on Palestinian parking attendants who requested he re-park his car in the correct section.
Despite these incidents and his criminal conviction, Israel’s high court rejected a petition to dismiss Ben-Gvir from his government position earlier this year.
Smotrich is equally divisive, proclaiming himself a “proud homophobe”, declaring on a trip to Paris that “there is no such thing as a Palestinian people”, and supporting the creation of “Greater Israel” which entails the invasion and occupation of Jordan, Syria, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia. In August, Smotrich invoked outrage globally after lamenting the international community’s insistence that humanitarian aid be provided to Gazans, musing that it may be “justified and moral” to starve out the population to achieve the hostages’ release.
This week, Israeli media reports indicate that Netanyahu is considering – or is in the process of implementing – similar proposals to those floated by Smotrich. The alleged plan involves a full siege on Gaza’s north, giving combatants and residents the choice to “surrender or starve”.
Israeli officials have denied that the plan is being executed. The IDF has given a recent mass evacuation order to Gazans in the northern area of the strip and yesterday, an IDF tank attack killed ten Palestinians as they queued for food.
While the Smotrich and Ben-Gvir represent relatively tiny parties in Israeli politics, their influence on Netanyahu’s war policy has been significant since October 7 because the governing coalition cannot survive without their support.
Critics and hostage families have continually expressed concerns as the duo have committed to blocking any ceasefire with Hamas or Hezbollah, eroding the potential for the release of captured Israelis through a deal Today, defence minister Yoav Gallant confirmed the distressed hostage families' worst fears stating, “there is no deal in sight”.
Hours after Cameron’s condemnation of the "extreme" ministers, the UK's foreign office announced additional sanctions targeting Israeli settlements in the West Bank. But whether Lammy heeds Cameron's advice on Smotrich and Ben-Gvir remains to be seen. Such a move could send a strong message to Netanyahu.
That said, an additional announcement today – from the American side – could go beyond the symbolic and increase pressure on Netanyahu to pay attention to international law. According to Axios, US secretaries Blinken and Austin have provided Israel with a thirty-day ultimatum: scrap the north Gaza plan and improve the humanitarian situation or some American military aid will be suspended indefinitely.
This is the most explicit warning so far from Israel’s key ally that support is not unconditional.
Josh Schlicht
Reaction Reporter
ON REACTION TODAY
Adam Boulton
Alex Salmond: a bathetic end for the man who nearly broke the union
Gabriel Lane
How the US and Canada took very different approaches to alleged Indian assassination plots
Reaction Podcast
A Long Time in Finance: the mystery of Dame Linda Dobbs
ALSO KNOW
NI rise could be on the cards - During a BBC Breakfast interview this morning, Keir Starmer refused to rule out a National Insurance increase for employers in the upcoming Budget, instead side-stepping questions over whether Labour’s manifesto promise not to raise taxes for "working people" covered NI. The Labour party's 2024 manifesto ruled out raising National Insurance, income tax and VAT.
Cervical cancer treatment breakthrough - Researchers funded by Cancer Research UK have made the biggest improvement in cervical cancer treatment in more than 20 years by changing how we use existing drugs. Results from the INTERLACE trial show that giving cervical cancer patients a short course of chemotherapy before starting the standard treatment cuts the risk of death by 40%. The new approach also cuts the risk of cervical cancer returning by 35%.
Speculation mounts over Israeli attack on Iran - Israel will listen to the US but will make final decisions based on its national interest, insists the Israeli prime minister's office, amid speculation over how it will respond to Iran's recent missile. Benjamin Netanyahu's office issued the statement in reponse to a Washington Post story which reported that Netanyahu had told Washington that its retaliatory attack against Iran wouldn’t hit nuclear or oil facilities but would instead target military and intelligence assets.
Tuchel could replace Gareth Southgate - The Football Association is in advanced talks with Thomas Tuchel over appointing him as the next England manager and it is understood that a deal could be put in place quickly. Tuchel, who led Chelsea to Champions League glory in 2021, has been out of work since leaving Bayern Munich in May.
FIVE THINGS
Curated by the Reaction Team - Gabriel Lane
1. The Rise and Fall of Cryptocurrency in Nigeria. Kingsley Charles in New Lines Magazine.
2. Why Beijing won’t give up on a failing economic model. Zongyuan Zoe Liu in Foreign Affairs.
3. Jane Street interns make more than Keir Starmer and Jay Powell, reports Robin Wigglesworth in The FT.
4. Fredrik Karrholm in The Spectator on why Sweden is cracking down on cousin marriages.
5. Should You be Nice to Your Chatbot? Preetika Rana in The Wall Street Journal.